Frequently cited as one of the worst if not the worst episodes in the whole franchise, "Spock's Brain" has infamy for certain. Does it deserve it?
Actually, probably not, if subsequent Star Trek history has anything to say about it. People attempted to "collect" Data no less than three times in The Next Generation ("The Measure of a Man," "The Most Toys," "A Matter of Time"), while Voyager featured similar scenarios multiple times as well (medical theft in "Phage," for instance, or "Think Tank," which sees Seven receive the Data treatment). That's a considerable legacy.
But "Spock's Brain" is also synonymous with the phrase "jumping the shark" (originated from Happy Days, with the Fonz pulling off the questionable move), and finds a latter-day comparison in the Voyager episode "Threshold," which suggests human evolution may lead to...lizards. It's the idea of Spock's brain being stolen that's considered ludicrous, Spock walking around without his brain.
|via Trek Core. On the other hand, NBC finally made a monster out of him.|
Except the franchise, like I said, seemed on the whole to think it was a pretty good idea. Granted, the later episodes unquestionably did much better stories with the concept, which in the end in, this incarnation, degenerates into a fairly standard and as a result generic and otherwise unmemorable story in the series. But the idea of it is not terrible. Most of it addresses very directly, as most of the best episodes of the series do, that it's Spock who's the real star. For a season that was basically one long Hail Mary for something that at that point wouldn't even dare dream of its later wide success as a franchise, that's shrewd thinking. Certainly not "Amok Time," but logical all the same.
It's time to let go of the stigma, folks. It's just another episode, and in some ways more than just another one, in a good way.
four quarter analysis
series * essential * character